Chapter 2 - THE WOMAN WITH THE SCAR
The silence in the grand foyer was so heavy it felt difficult to breathe.
Vincent Caruso stood perfectly still, his dark eyes locked on the woman standing outside the glass doors.
Thirty-two elite guests murmured in confusion.
I held ten-year-old Leo against my side. His small hands gripped my apron so tightly his knuckles were white.
“Leo,” Vincent said, his voice dropping to a dangerous whisper. “What do you mean, she pretended Mom died?”
“Uncle Daniel told her what to wear,” the boy whispered back, his voice trembling. “He told her to drive Mom’s car to the bridge.”
Sabrina Vale, Vincent’s fiancée, let out a harsh, panicked laugh.
“Vincent, the boy is delusional! He needs psychiatric help immediately. That woman is clearly a grifter Daniel hired to upset you.”
But Vincent didn’t look at Sabrina.
He didn’t look at the armed guards standing by the mahogany doors.
He marched straight toward the entrance and threw the doors open himself.
The winter wind howled into the mansion, blowing snow across the marble floor.
The woman dropped her suitcase.
She stared at Vincent, her breath pluming in the freezing air.
Up close, the resemblance was absolutely terrifying. She had Isabella’s exact cheekbones. Isabella’s dark, expressive eyes.
But her hair was shorter. And the jagged scar above her left eyebrow looked like it had barely healed.
“Who are you?” Vincent demanded, stepping onto the porch.
The woman swallowed hard. “Vincent.”
Vincent flinched. Even her voice was the same.
“I won’t ask you again,” Vincent warned, pulling a dark steel pistol from beneath his tailored jacket. He didn’t aim it, but the threat was explicit. “If my brother paid you to mock my dead wife, I will kill you right here on the steps.”
The woman didn’t back away.
She reached into the collar of her wool coat.
With trembling fingers, she pulled out a silver necklace.
Hanging from the chain was a small, diamond-encrusted pendant shaped like a swallow.
Vincent stopped breathing.
“I gave Isabella that necklace on our fifth anniversary,” he whispered. “She was wearing it the night she died. The police said it was lost in the fire.”
“It wasn’t lost,” the woman said, tears spilling over her cold cheeks. “I took it off her before Daniel’s men pushed the car into the ravine.”
Sabrina rushed forward, her white designer gown dragging across the snow.
“Arrest her!” Sabrina shrieked to the guards. “She just confessed to murder!”
“I didn’t kill her!” the woman shouted, her eyes locking onto Sabrina with pure hatred. “You and Daniel did! You poisoned her at dinner, and Daniel forced me to take her place in the car so the autopsy would show blunt force trauma instead of toxins!”
The guests in the hallway gasped.
I felt a cold chill wash over my entire body.
“Wait,” I said, stepping forward. I couldn’t stop myself. I looked at the woman’s scar. “If you were in the car when it went into the ravine… how did you survive?”
The woman looked at me, then down at Leo.
Her expression softened into something so agonizingly tender it broke my heart.
“I jumped before it hit the bottom,” she whispered. “Daniel’s men thought I was dead. They left me in the freezing mud. But I dragged myself to the highway.”
Vincent’s hands were shaking. The undisputed king of the Chicago syndicate was trembling.
“Who are you?” Vincent begged, his voice cracking. “Tell me who you are.”
The woman looked back at him.
“My name is Elena,” she said. “Isabella was my twin sister.”
Vincent staggered back a step. “Isabella didn’t have a sister. She grew up in foster care.”
“We were separated when we were four,” Elena said, wiping her eyes. “She found me three months before she died. She told me she was in trouble. She told me her husband’s brother was stealing from her son, and she needed my help to expose him.”
Sabrina suddenly lunged toward the guards.
“She’s lying! Shoot her! She’s a trespasser!”
But Vincent raised his hand, and the guards didn’t move a muscle.
“Elena,” Vincent said slowly, lowering his weapon. “If you survived… why didn’t you come to me three years ago?”
Elena looked down at the suitcase resting in the snow.
“Because Daniel took something from me,” she whispered. “He told me if I ever approached you, he would kill her.”
Vincent frowned. “Kill who?”
Elena knelt in the snow and clicked open the latches of her suitcase.
She didn’t pull out clothes. Or documents.
She pulled back a thick wool blanket.
And lifted a sleeping, three-year-old toddler into her arms.
The little girl had a head full of dark curls.
Vincent dropped his gun. It clattered against the marble floor.
“Daniel kidnapped her the night of the crash,” Elena sobbed, holding the child tightly. “He kept her hidden to guarantee my silence.”
Vincent fell to his knees in the snow.
He stared at the little girl’s face.
Then he looked up at Elena, his eyes wide with a horrifying realization.
“Elena,” Vincent choked out. “Whose child is that?”
Elena looked at Leo, who was crying silently by my side.
May you like
Then she looked back at Vincent.
“She’s not mine, Vincent,” Elena whispered. “She’s Isabella’s. And she’s yours.”
