Chapter 2 - THE JUDGE AT THE TABLE
Vincent Salvatore did not blink.
He did not breathe.
He stared at the handwritten letter from his dead father, the heavy red wax crumbling between his tightening fingers.
The man who sent Arthur Bennett to prison forty years earlier is still alive. And he is sitting at your dinner table.
Vincent slowly lowered the parchment.
The grand dining room, filled with sixty of New York’s elite, suddenly felt entirely devoid of oxygen. The clinking of crystal glasses and soft murmurs of conversation faded into a muted, underwater hum in my ears.
Vincent’s dark eyes swept across the length of the mahogany table.
Past the wealthy socialites.
Past the corrupt politicians Margaret had invited.
Until his gaze locked onto a man sitting three chairs away.
Judge Thomas Vance.
Seventy-one years old. Silver hair, perfectly combed. A pillar of the New York judicial system. He was currently sipping a glass of imported Merlot, looking completely at ease.
Judge Vance had been a “friend” of the Salvatore family since Vincent was a boy. He had attended Joseph Salvatore’s funeral. He had even signed the permits for Vincent’s new downtown casino.
Vincent’s hands began to shake. Not out of fear, but from a rage so profound it seemed to vibrate through the floorboards.
“Vance,” Vincent whispered.
The name sliced through the silence.
Judge Vance lowered his wineglass. He dabbed his mouth with a linen napkin and offered a warm, grandfatherly smile.
“Yes, Vincent? Was there something else in Joseph’s letter?” Vance asked smoothly.
Vincent didn't answer. He walked slowly around the table, his footsteps heavy and deliberate.
Arthur Bennett gripped the edge of his wooden chair. The seventy-four-year-old driver’s face had drained of all color.
“Son, please,” Arthur rasped, his voice trembling violently. “Don’t do this. He’s too powerful.”
Vincent stopped directly behind Judge Vance’s chair.
“Forty years ago,” Vincent said, his voice terrifyingly calm. “My father’s trucking company was investigated for moving unlicensed cargo. But my father didn't go to federal prison. His driver did.”
Judge Vance sighed, adjusting his silk tie.
“It was a different time, Vincent. Your father was a complex man who made difficult choices. Arthur volunteered to take the fall. It was an honorable sacrifice.”
“A sacrifice?” Vincent repeated.
He slammed his hand onto the table. Crystal glasses shattered. Three women screamed.
“You were the federal prosecutor on that case!” Vincent roared, the polished mafia boss entirely disappearing, replaced by a son demanding blood. “You prosecuted Arthur! You sent a good man to a concrete cell for five years!”
The dinner guests began to stand, panic rippling through the room.
Judge Vance didn't flinch. He slowly stood up, buttoning his suit jacket.
“Your father paid me handsomely to ensure his own name stayed out of the indictments,” Vance said coldly, dropping the friendly facade. “I did him a favor. And now, you are making a scene over a washed-up servant.”
“He is family!” Vincent shouted.
“He is collateral damage,” Vance corrected smoothly. “Just like his crippled daughter. And just like that ten-year-old grandson of his.”
Arthur let out a choked gasp.
My heart stopped.
I looked at Arthur. “You have a grandson?”
Tears spilled down the old man’s wrinkled cheeks. “Leo. Catherine’s boy. They’re both at the cottage.”
Judge Vance smiled, looking at his gold wristwatch.
“Actually, Arthur, I heard about Margaret’s eviction notice,” Vance said, his voice dripping with malice. “Since I am a partner in Vivian Whitmore’s new real estate venture, I took the liberty of sending some men to the cottage to help your daughter and grandson pack. They should have arrived about twenty minutes ago.”
Vincent’s face went completely pale.
“If you touch them,” Vincent breathed, pulling a dark steel handgun from beneath his tailored jacket, “I will kill you in front of this entire room.”
Several guests shrieked and bolted for the front doors.
Vance didn't look afraid. He leaned forward.
“Shoot a federal judge in front of sixty witnesses, Vincent. See how long your empire lasts. You’ll be in a cell next to Arthur before sunrise.”
Vincent’s finger tightened on the trigger.
“Mr. Salvatore, wait!” I yelled, grabbing his arm. “Catherine and Leo! We have to get to the cottage!”
Vincent stared into my eyes. His chest heaved. He realized I was right. Bloodshed here wouldn't save Arthur’s family.
He lowered the gun and turned to his security chief. “Lock the estate doors. No one leaves. Especially not him.”
Vincent grabbed Arthur’s arm. “Come with me.”
“I’m coming too,” I said.
Vincent didn't argue. We sprinted out the side doors, rushing into the freezing New York night. Vincent didn't wait for his drivers. He jumped into the driver’s seat of his black SUV, Arthur and I scrambling into the back.
The tires screamed against the asphalt as we tore down the private driveway toward the back of the massive estate, heading for the apple orchard.
“Please, God,” Arthur wept into his hands. “Not my daughter. Not my Leo.”
“I won’t let them be hurt, Arthur,” Vincent swore, gripping the steering wheel so hard his knuckles were white.
The cottage sat in a dark clearing behind the bare, skeletal apple trees.
As the headlights swept across the small white house, my stomach dropped into a bottomless pit.
The front door was completely shattered, hanging off its hinges.
Vincent slammed the brakes. We jumped out before the car even stopped.
“Catherine!” Arthur screamed, running as fast as his stiff knees would allow.
We burst into the living room.
The place had been destroyed. Furniture overturned. Eleanor Bennett’s beautiful porcelain plates smashed into hundreds of pieces. The couch cushions were ripped open, feathers drifting through the cold air.
But there was no sign of the men.
And there was no sign of Catherine or little Leo.
“Catherine!” Arthur sobbed, dropping to his knees among the broken glass. “Leo!”
I frantically searched the kitchen. Empty.
Vincent moved toward the hallway, his gun raised, sweeping the dark corners.
“Emily,” Vincent called out. His voice was shaking.
I ran to the hallway.
Vincent was standing frozen outside Catherine’s bedroom.
I looked down.
Sitting in the middle of the wooden floor was a heavy silver rosary. I recognized it immediately. Catherine had been holding it the day I brought them groceries last week.
May you like
But it wasn’t just the rosary that made Vincent stop.
Beneath the silver cross was a dark, fresh pool of blood trailing toward the back window.
